SAQ and How to receive on vlf

For questions and remarks: paul(at)prinz.nl
When my collegue Andre mentioned the frequency, I thought: wow , this is an audio
frequency: 17.2 kHz! What antenna to use, and what sort of receiver? How not to receive all the switching power supplies that we have in use? On this web page I will write my findings and you might be inspired to also try to receive the very long wavelengths.

Today is the day after. Yesterday it was the 24th of October 2020, the UN celebrated it's 75th birthday. I worked for the UN from 2004 to 2007 and I feel it still is a bit my organisation. Yesterday it was the first day that we, the partners in crime team, could test the preamplifier with tuned ferrite rod. Please have a look at the pictures and the sound files.

I made these spectrum pictures in my car, at location just outside my village. The preamp with tuned ferrite rod was pointing east-west, so reception was north-south. I tuned the rod using 1kHz bandwidth as you can hear the audio pitch changing. After that I used 300Hz CW bandwith for receiving the message. Noise level can be seen at the left, around -75dB. Key down is at the right, a level of -45dB. This means a S/N of 30dB, an amazing level! Below I will add some more pictures and the sound files recorded with the SAQ panoramic receiver software.
Wilhelm was also on the road parking at a quiet spot. He also received SAQ with very comparable figures.

Please have a listen to this audio file. I recorded it on the 24th of October 2020 inside my car. It was the message transmitted for the celebration of the UN 75th birthday.

The Receiver: I checked several web sites to see what other people are doing and I saw 3 solutions:

First solution: Superheteodyne receiver.
See the website vlf.it . Look for: A very simple VLF Pocket receiver by By Wilfried Fritz, DJ1WF. It is a classical super heteodyne receiver with an IF of about 455 kHz and a BFO. Using a short whip receiving the E-field.

Second solution: PC, Laptop, Sound card.
This solution comes from the Alexander association, the guys that run and maintain the old Grimeton Station. The transmitted frequencies are that low that they can be directly received by a laptops soundcard. The PC then can use a simple SDR programme to process the incoming frequency. More information can be found using this link:

Receive SAQ

It suggest to use a PC or laptop, take the build in sound card, and receive it directly. As most sound cards sample on 44.1 kHz or 48 kHz, the spectrum up to half of the sampling frequency, so 22 or 24 kHz can be received.

Third Solution: Upconverter.
The third option is to upconvert this low frequency and convert it to a frequency that most short wave receivers can handle.

I have chosen to explore the second solution: use a laptop with sound card. When you have a look on the Alexander Associations web site, you will see that SM6LKM, Johan Bodin, wrote a nice SDR program. It receives a carrier in the vlf band up to about 24 kHz and demodulate it. It easily installed on my laptop and this part of the game was done.
The software can be found here:
https://sites.google.com/site/swljo30tb/home/files
.

I have found a contribution on a radio communication board: www.theradioboard.com. It's a 2013 contribution from Broesel out of Villach, Austria. Thanks Broesel. He published a front-end using a ferrite rod and capacitor tuned with parallel resonance to about 15-20 kHz. The front-end uses a jfet as preamp in grounded source configuration and the output is fed to a soundcard of a laptop. His contribution is found below.

I changed his contrbution a bit to allow easy reproduction. I am using a varicap (varactor, capacitance diode) with a potentiometer to tune the preamp. I used a simple load resistor and not a complex combination of LCLC as it is too difficult to make. A simple R as load reduces the gain compared to the LCLC solution, but still provides enough gain in the stage to get a good pre-amp.

I used a japanese mosfet at first as was available, but other fet's will work fine too.

After everything was working, I tried to reverse engineer the Coil. I found out the following things:
Over here in Europe, most ferrite rods are made of only a few ferrite materials,

all from Ferroxcube Philips: 4B1 and 3B1.
Well, I did some more searching and the list is a bit larger:
4B2, 3C90, 3S3 and 3F3 ferrite material.
The permeability mu is the important parameter, the higher the mu, the less windings to make for the same induction L. I will sum up the mu value for the different ferrites:
4B1: 250, 4B2: 250, 3B1: 900, 3C90: 2300, 3S3: 350, 3F3: 2000

So we see quite a difference and we want to go for a rod of 3C90 or 3F3 material, otherwise we wil go for a 3B1 rod, that's also fine.

You can also look at it from a material perspective. What material the rod is made from? I believe this gives a good indication:
NiZn so Nickel Zinc. mu value of a few hundred, used for some MHz
MnZn so Mangan Zinc, mu value of around one thousand or so, used for some kHz
The datasheets will tell what materials are used.
So if no mu is given, get a MnZn rod. I will verify this by testing.
This website Ferroxcube gives good info on material and mu.

What I did to buy the rods? :

I went to the website: COIL to calculate the inductance L for a mu of 250 (4B1) or 900 (3B1).

I measured the inductance of my creation and it is only is 74mH. OK.
I used L = 74mH, length rod = 600mm(long), diameter rod = 10mm, mu = 250. Diameter coil former is the same as rod diameter: 10mm, shift =11mm(?), wire diameter=0.25mm, winding pitch:0.26mm.
The answer is: 888 turns.
This is good. I did do around 900 turns, analysis correct, this rod on my picture has mu=250.

Clearly not a rod with a mu of 900, 2000 or more.

So where do we get high mu ferrite rods:

A. I looked at the webshop box73.de. I went to the page with the ferrite rods:
Ferrite Rod at box73.de
Here you can buy a rod of 3B1 material and diameter of 8mm: number of turns: 665.

B. The second source is ebay.de and the webshop:
electronic-componentsseller
He sells various ferrite material, when you seach for "FERRIT" AND "3F3" you will find a great ferrite rod of 3F3 material with a length of 100mm. Diameter: 8mm, number of turns: 522.

It will not get much lower, dear readers!

Conclusions:
A. The 10mm diameter rod i bought has a mu of about 250, 4B1, NiZn

B. When you buy a 8mm diameter 3B1 rod, it only needs 665 turns, MnZn

C. The 3F3 rod on ebay.de (C) only needs 522 turns and is cheap. Get it!
update: Don't get it, it needed 1200 turns, website shows not correct information.

After I wrote the words above, I did buy 3 of the 3F3 Rods above. After making a small coil and measuring the inductance, I thought hmmm. The 3F3 rods are not 3F3 rods. These rods have a mu of around 250-300. What I learned here, you can not always trust what is written. I have bought the 3B1 rods from box73.de . I will test them next week.

The week is over and I have tested the 3B1 rod from box73.de . The results are: to get an L of 82mH, number of windings n = 1030 . This is not what I expected, as the mu = 350 or so. This means that also this rod needs around 900 - 1000 windings.

Maybe I should repeat my first Rod conclusion: buy the longest and fattest rod you can get, do around 900 - windings and be happy! Maybe easier than looking for the holy grail.

The Coil I connected to the preamplifier. The preamplifier is using a 9V battery to keeps things portable. Its rechargable, the preamp uses small power, you can listen the whole day outside and recharge it over night. Pointing the ferrite rod towards Sweden will give you minimum reception, it's a sharp null, the rod needs to be perpendicular to SAQ. That's not critical, and you can use this maximising and minimising to cancel out a disturbing carrier on a nearby frequency.

About the schematics:
The gain of this preamp is the gain of a common source configuration. This is basically : Av = -gm x Ro. Ro is the parallel set of 3 'resistors', ro of the fet itself, Rd (2k7-4k7) and Ri of the sound card (assumed 10k). ro of the fet is much higher than the other two, so can be neglected. Ri is something that can not be influenced, and Rd can be chosen. I chose Rd a few times smaller than Ri, so that the gain is determined mostly by the preamp and not by the sound card. I chose Rd high enough not so have a lot of Id as it would draw the 9V battery empty. I chose a fet with relatively high gm at lower currents, and a small capacitance Crss between gate and drain. This is important as we have a resonant circuit at the input, and Crss gives feedback from the output back to the input. At the beginning I used a fet with a Crss of 6pF and it made the preamp oscillate. Crss of smaller than 1pF is recommended. Ci smaller than 30pF is also fine, this is not so critical.
A small resistor is series with the gate (gatestopper) is used to avoid oscillation at VHF frequencies.
The 4M7 resistor grounds the gate, so that the fet is set also when the coil is disconnected.
The resonant circuit is made of the ferrite rod inductance together with 2 capacitance diodes and a fixed capacitor. The 2 capacitance diodes have a total capacitance of about 1000pF or 1nF. The fixed capacitor is chosen such that resonance occurs a bit below the SAQ frequency of 17 kHz. I selected 330pF, so a total Cp = 1330pF. With an L of 82mH, fres minimum = 15 kHz. The actual fres min was a bit lower, so i guess that the capacitance diodes have a capacitance a bit higher than 500pF each at 0V. At 8 or 9V, the capacitance diodes only have a capacitance of 34pF max each, so Cp (8V) total is 68pF + 330pF = 400pF. Therefore fres max = 27 kHz. This gives us a frequency range of 15-27 kHz and that is fine. If you want a higher fres max, remove the fixed capacitor and use 3 capacitance diodes in parallel.
The diodes draw a little current, i measured 1V drop over the 1Mohm resistor, so both capacitance diodes draw 1 uA in total. No big deal.

Shopping List
FET 2SK241-GR, tested and preferred, 2SK161-GR Rd = 2k7 and Rs = 330 Ohm or

FET 2SK161-Y, tested. Rd = 4k7 and Rs = 470 Ohm. Works fine.

FET 2SK193-p or k. Rd = 2k2 and Rs = 47 Ohm or

FET 2SK522-d. Rd = 2k2 Ohm and Rs = 220 Ohm or

FET 2N3819, Rd=2k7, measure Ud and change Rs so that Ud = 4.5V +/-1V or

FET BF410b. Rd=2k7, measure Ud and change Rs so that Ud = 4.5V +/-1V or
FET                      BF987. Tested.preferred.Rd=4k7,Id = 0.5mA,Rs = 1kOhm. Pinning below near picture
FET                      2N5485 or 86. Rd=2k7, measure Ud and change Rs so that Ud = 4.5V +/-1V
FET                      BFW10 or 11 or 2N4416. Rd=2k7, measure Ud and change Rs so that Ud = 4.5V +/-1V

Ferrite Rod round, diameter 8-10mm, length 100-200mm, if you can choose: high mu

Wire lacquered or enamelled copper wire, 0.25 - 0.3 mm, 30m length

Varicap BB112 (EU) or 1SV149(Japan) 2x or one KV1270, KV1560 or BB212 (2 diodes in one)

9V Use 9V monoblock. Simple. Rechargable or not.

LED Use a bright LED with bias resistor. R=10-22kOhm. So you don't forget to switch off

Potmeter 22k. Any lineair potentiometer will do. Value from 10k to 100kOhm.

The picture above left shows a small PCB that I have created. For people that are interested, send an email to paul(at)prinz.nl . The rod I used here is the 3B1 rod I bought from box73.de . With the potentiometer I tune from around 13 kHz up to 26 kHz. This set up I am putting in a small wooden box to be prepared for the SAQ Christmas transmission. The results look promising.

At the right you see how to connect the BF987 fet as the datasheet is not very clear. I bought some more of them, if you want I can provide the fet to you.

SAQ Panoramic VLF Receiver v0.94
OK. My collegues and brothers in arms are also preparing themselves to receive the October 24 2020 transmission.
And of course some issues are popping up to be discussed over here.
The SDR Panoramic receiver from SM6LKM has it's little issues, easily to overcome. SM6LKM states that the software is designed for Windows XP. But....I have two laptops over here, one on Windows 7 and one on Windows 10. Both of them run this SDR software. When you run the software, i.e. SAQ48k, the following error occurs:

This happens on both Windows 7 and Windows 10.
This error is related to the program not seing any audio input. When you do not have any microphone or line input activated, this error occurs. Your audio recording devices look like this:

Here you can see that the bottom input is disabled and the middle input shows that the cable is not plugged in. When I plug in the cable from the preamp, it looks like this:

Even when you do plug in an audio cable, this action is sometimes not recognised. This means that our famous microsoft product did hang itself up. Restarting the laptop always solves this issue and then you will get the picture above. Only when you have the picture above it is useful to start SAQrx and then it will always start up properly.
So make sure your audio input is activated and then start SAQrx

For Windows 10 it looks like this:

Sorry for the German language, but I guess that you will understand:

The next topic is the CW bandwidth. When the program starts up, the CW bandwidth is set to 1 kHz.

Like here on this picture.

By accident I clicked on the CW button again and voila: the bandwidth changed! Please try this out for yourself. I like the 300Hz setting as it fits nicely to the RTTY PSK and FSK transmissions to the submarines. I will check out what filts well to the SAQ cw transmission.

This is an update of July 2021. There has been an SAQ transmission on Alexander day, unfortunately I couldn't listen as I was travelling. But a few weeks later, I got an email from PE7B, Paul Webster, informing me that he also build this ferrite rod preamplifier. If you want to, have a look at this youtube channel :
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AB-oNT4-0KY
Paul has some other interesting topics to share. I guess this is what it all about: creating, sharing and see what others do, so also give it a try!

It is October 2021. Two things have happened.
1. I travelled to Egypt and I took the receiver with me.
2. We got an invitation for the UN-day celebration from SAQ.

To start with the first topic. I travelled to Alexandria, Egypt and I had the possibility to check out the submarine transmitters. I will show the picture of the spectrum:

Mobirise
A few things can be observed on this spectrum. I have used a bit preamplifier gain in the laptop. This added gain can be seen by the raised noise floor of about 90dB.
I tuned to JXN, Norway. This station was transmitting, the signal was there but not that strong.
At the other end, the reception was clear, it was a quiet spot and I could well hear this station. S/N was still about 10dB, after reducing the bandwidth to 300Hz, the signal was fine.
We are talking about a distance of about 4000km. That is not bad at all!
Also visible are GBZ, UK at 19.6kHz, HWU, France at 20.9kHz and DH038 at 23.4 kHz .
It is very visible that the S/N of around 30-40dB in the Netherlands of Germany is reduced to may 10-20dB at the mediterrenean coast of Egypt. Nut nevertheless all these station are well received. I can only encourage readers to try out and report the results to us.

Grimeton or Varberg Station, call sign SAQ

VLF receiver SDR on laptop from SM6LKM

Ferrite Rod with Copper Coil

What to receive?